Edwin Evans-Thirlwell


153 games reviewed
71.5 average score
75 median score
54.5% of games recommended
Are you Edwin Evans-Thirlwell? If so, email [email protected] to claim this critic page.
Unscored - Death of a Wish
Mar 15, 2024

A tormented action fantasy that has heart, imagination and style in spades.

Read full review

Jan 10, 2024

An immense, clever and often fascinating deep dive into the Warhammer 40K world that has its fair share of obfuscation, filler and inelegance.

Read full review

Unscored - Starfield
Aug 31, 2023

A short, sparky and colourful 2D PICO-8 blaster about a space captain fighting fascist robots.

Read full review

Unscored - Fort Solis
Aug 22, 2023

A short-lived yet slowburn sci-fi drama about two engineers exploring a spooky, beautifully designed Martian base that's let down by a general lack of inspiration and especially, a dissatisfying plot.

Read full review

Aug 16, 2023

A splendid, engrossing blend of visual novel and card creation game, where the cards you create are the means of navigating dialogue and pursuing a story about outcast witches, their griefs, lusts and more destructive tendencies.

Read full review

Jun 23, 2020

Persona 4 is a twisting tale of dreams gone rogue in a town sapped of purpose. It brings personal demons to life in gaudy but plausible ways, and uses this to rejuvenate the dog-eared framework of a town-and-dungeon fantasy RPG. Unceremonious as it is, the PC port leaves all of that peculiar magic intact. It’s just a shame that the insight and empathy on show here doesn’t extend to everybody.

Read full review

May 18, 2020

This is far from the most polished remaster I’ve played, and the original was a hit-and-miss affair to begin with. Judged in terms of Platinum’s own end-of-level trophies, this earns a silver award at best.

Read full review

Unscored - Kine
Oct 16, 2019

Even though Kine does a great job of drip-feeding you its complexities, I hit a wall once I reached the main stage.

Read full review

Nov 1, 2017

Origins handles its creative inheritance more elegantly than some open worlders, not least because unlike, say, the first game's Altair, its protagonist actually feels like he is of this realm rather than merely in it. And if the levelling and to-do list grate, the series has never offered a society and a landscape so worthy of close attention.

Read full review

Feb 13, 2018

The measure of an open world is ultimately not the story it tells but whether you're happy to kill time within it, and Kingdom Come: Deliverance offers plenty of ways to do that, even if a lot of them will, in fact, get you slaughtered.

Read full review

Unscored - Those Who Remain
May 28, 2020

A couple of nifty concepts can't save this uninspired genre piece from its shortage of character or fear.

Read full review

Nov 29, 2018

A blatantly unfinished and uninspired nostalgia project that sheds a certain, peculiar light on the immersive sim at large.

Read full review

Avoid - High on Life
Dec 12, 2022

A miserable cocktail of ideas from other action-platformers and the worst parts of Rick and Morty.

Read full review

May 17, 2018

Technically shambolic, obsessed with hoarding, and a waste of a once-promising society simulation.

Read full review

Jun 21, 2016

A woeful continuation of the Blood Dragon universe that splices Trials' brilliant handling with some torturously bad subgames.

Read full review

No Recommendation / Blank - Dead Island 2
Apr 18, 2023

A straightforwardly accomplished zombie action-RPG that doesn't quite make the most of its Californian setting.

Read full review

No Recommendation / Blank - Dredge
Mar 23, 2023

Blending fishing with Gothic horror and Lovecraft is a fine hook, but Dredge is too defined by simple loot-and-upgrade rhythms to reel you in.

Read full review

No Recommendation / Blank - Wanted: Dead
Feb 14, 2023

All the confusing yet irresistible energy of early-noughties double-A gaming, marred by awful writing and a core gimmick that doesn't ignite.

Read full review

No Recommendation / Blank - Dead Space (Remake)
Jan 26, 2023

While a fine piece of craft and a sumptuous reworking of the setting, EA Motive's Dead Space remake sheds a little of the 2008 game's enchantment.

Read full review

No Recommendation / Blank - Overwatch 2
Oct 14, 2022

An aimless-feeling revamp of 2016's best multiplayer game, slightly coarsened by free-to-play grinding.

Read full review