Reid McCarter


74 games reviewed
70.0 average score
70 median score
34.3% of games recommended
Are you Reid McCarter? If so, email [email protected] to claim this critic page.

A Knight to Remember manages to capture the spirit of its predecessors without ever feeling like an empty exercise in nostalgia.

Read full review

Life Is Strange's conclusion cements its story as one of the more noteworthy in recent videogames.

Read full review

Ultimate Edition doesn’t represent a drastic change from the Xbox 360 original.

Read full review

Nov 10, 2014

This is Call of Duty coming to terms with itself—pushing and pulling between social responsibility and the joy of instinctual, itchy trigger-fingered chaos. Not since Modern Warfare has an entry to the series felt much more than casually disinterested in humanity.

Read full review

78 / 100 - Until Dawn
Aug 24, 2015

Until Dawn is a game constructed by people who understand how to manipulate its players' sense of control. It's informed by a deep study of horror films and smart in its consideration of how to employ this understanding in an interactive medium. It only fails in its uncharacteristic acceptance of a few outmoded tropes. In some ways that enhances Until Dawn as an attempt to properly translate its genre to a new form, while keeping its spirit intact. In others, it's a disappointingly familiar problem to find in a game with so many novel ideas.

Read full review

78 / 100 - SUPERHOT
Feb 25, 2016

There is no shooter quite as willing to prostrate itself before its audience as SUPERHOT while always reminding them that, no matter how tough the game may make them feel, that same sensation can be stolen from them in a heartbeat.

Read full review

76 / 100 - Evolve
Feb 17, 2015

When the pieces come together as they're meant to, Evolve is satisfying in a bone-deep kind of way.

Read full review

76 / 100 - Not a Hero
May 25, 2015

Not a Hero's ultimate statement is a brutally cynical one, but its political nihilism is always portrayed with such glee and good cheer that the unease is hard to feel until the game is shut down.

Read full review

May 1, 2017

Given its wide scope, it's understandable that it's also a game that succeeds more in concept than execution. Like the subjects of the multi-generational novels whose tradition it embraces, Edith Finch's individual successes and failures are less important than its overall effect. It's a story made of stories, and the results of its breadth seem more important than the fine details.

Read full review

7.5 / 10.0 - Splatoon 2
Jul 18, 2017

Even though Splatoon 2 outdoes the first game in every technical sense, it still feels lesser simply because it's more of the same. What was captivatingly eccentric in 2015 feels safer now, its quirks predictable even though they're still impressive. Get lost in the speed and noise of one of its matches and it might not seem like any of these problems matter, but a slower, sober moment looking at Splatoon 2 as a whole makes it difficult to ignore.

Read full review

Feb 17, 2016

Though Rise of the Tomb Raider wastes little time in getting Lara into the thick of a brand new adventure, it's still burdened by much of its predecessor's baggage.

Read full review

71 / 100 - Bravely Default
Feb 6, 2014

Bravely Default is, for better or worse, a pretty good '90s RPG

Read full review

Assassin's Creed Valhalla's vision of ninth-century England is a beautiful place to explore, populated with a great cast of characters who make up for the bland new protagonist, Eivor. Nevertheless, the tired overarching story of Templars and Assassins, and a design ethos that overstuffs the setting with side activities, add unnecessary bloat and distractions to the experience. Valhalla's a solid action-adventure game that does well to capture the turmoil of its historical era, but it's weighed down by the increasingly ponderous legacy of the series it represents.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Battlefield 1
Oct 24, 2016

Its developer is afraid of settling down for even a moment, worried that players will grow bored with even a second of necessary peace. This approach works in the meat-grinder of multiplayer and the series of American corpses of its opening moments, but fails elsewhere. The result is a game pulling in all directions, aesthetically coherent, but with a muddled design ethos that allows it to come near something extraordinary without ever quite achieving it.

Read full review

Jan 19, 2015

Resident Evil HD Remaster . . . achieves the same sense of lingering horror as its source material while simultaneously making the entire experience easier for modern audiences to appreciate.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Costume Quest 2
Oct 30, 2014

Costume Quest 2 is at its best when the repetitive role-playing combat system takes a backseat to its adventure-style exploration and dialogue.

Read full review

Dec 17, 2014

Leviathan often feels more like a short novel than it does a traditional videogame.

Read full review

May 23, 2014

Vagabond Dog has developed a title that, despite its rough edges, ends up offering an interesting look at a character coming to grips with themselves and their place in the world.

Read full review

Sep 5, 2014

Every part of [Dead Rising 3] exists in service to the simple act of knocking over zombies like so many shuffling bowling pins.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Halfway
Aug 5, 2014

[Halfway's] developer is an enormous fan of a few things: well-crafted pixel art, 1980s science fiction movies, and XCOM.

Read full review