Percentile Rank

Pony Island is ranked in the 94th percentile of games scored on OpenCritic.

Rating Summary

Based on 17 critic reviews
Mighty Man

OpenCritic Rating

85

Top Critic Average

81%

Critics Recommend

Based on 17 critic reviews

Score Distribution

Unscored Reviews

Rock, Paper, Shotgun
Unscored
Unscored
Jan 5, 2016

[T]rust me, pick this one up.

Read full review

Scored Reviews

The Jimquisition
9.5 / 10.0
9.5 / 10.0
Jan 8, 2016

Pony Island is bloody genius.

Read full review

Destructoid
9.5 / 10.0
9.5 / 10.0
Jan 10, 2016

Pony Island messes with players in unexpected ways that stuck with me for days. It took a number of unexpected turns that caught me off guard and was constantly filling me with a sense of inescapable unease. It wasn't on my radar at all before it released, but at under $5 it's a wonderful use of two hours of your life.

Read full review

PC Gamer
91 / 100
91 / 100
Jan 22, 2016

Sharp, multilayered satire that remembers to be a game even as it makes fun of us for playing.

Read full review

VideoGamer
9 / 10
9 / 10
Jan 7, 2016

I haven't played anything as engaging and interesting as Pony Island in a long time.

Read full review

Metro GameCentral
9 / 10
9 / 10
Jan 8, 2016

A fantastically clever deconstruction of video games and the people that play them, as well as a hugely entertaining action puzzler that's not really about ponies.

Read full review

Hardcore Gamer
4.5 / 5.0
4.5 / 5.0
Jan 15, 2016

Don't read anymore reviews; don't watch any videos. Just play this game. Any further coverage will only detract from your enjoyment.

Read full review

God is a Geek
9 / 10.0
9 / 10.0
Jan 19, 2016

Games have taught us to expect the expected, but Pony Island throws the rulebook out the window in this puzzle-cum-runner title where you must escape Satan's clutches.

Read full review

IGN
9 / 10.0
IGN

Top Critic

9 / 10.0
Jan 18, 2016

I greatly enjoyed the two or so hours it took me to play through Pony Island. This is a game that delights in toying with your expectations and in breaking the fourth wall, in revealing its sinister yet playful world, and in building up a compelling antagonist and telling an ambiguous story. Pony Island is about as punk rock as they come.

Read full review

Softpedia
8.5 / 10.0
8.5 / 10.0
Jan 6, 2016

Pony Island is a small game that will never manage to get the audience of an AAA release but in many ways, this game is more engaging than plenty of the big launches of last fall because it features some truly innovative moments and can deliver a narrative that it's disturbing and interesting to the end.

Read full review

GameCrate
8.5 / 10.0
8.5 / 10.0
Jan 29, 2016

Due to the fact that Pony Island only asks a minor investment in terms of both time and price point ($5), but even more so because it's just so much fun, it falls under "must-play" territory and provides a vastly different experience from other modern-day indies.

Read full review

New Game Network
81 / 100
81 / 100
Mar 13, 2016

Pony Island is clever, creative and veritably ludicrous. It's not heavy on mechanics, and puzzles can slow down the experience, but its satanic tendencies and cultural observations endures far beyond its prompt closure. Neither for, nor about ponies.

Read full review

GameSpew
8 / 10
8 / 10
Jan 25, 2016

In an attempt to frame the antagonistic nature of the designer/player dynamic and ask why a game can't be simple, uncomplicated fun, Mullins has saddled his creation with an incredibly tedious third act

Read full review

The Escapist
Jan 13, 2016

Pony Island is an incredibly clever puzzle-horror game that manages to immerse you in a screwed up world of ponies, code, and demonic machinations.

Read full review

Game Informer
7.5 / 10.0
7.5 / 10.0
Jan 29, 2016

Pony Island's action sequences are repetitive and unforgiving, but the bizarre narrative doles out intrigue and humor in equal parts

Read full review

IGN Italy
7.5 / 10.0
7.5 / 10.0
Jan 24, 2016

Pony Island is a unique, weird, impossible-to-descrive little game. It's clever, often surprising and with tons of personality, but its mechanics can prove a bit repetitive.

Review in Italian | Read full review

games(TM)
7 / 10
games(TM)
games™ Team

Top Critic

7 / 10
Apr 17, 2016

Clever, unique, inventive but brief and repetitive

Read full review