Mafia: Definitive Edition

Sort by:
Ivory_Soul
8 / 10.0
I remember Mafia back in the early days of the PS2 era. I also remember not really understanding it because I was 12 years old and probably shouldn't have been playing a Mafia game. I also remember the game being hard as nails, but that's about it. 18 years later, Mafia is a classic and a surprising choice for a full-on remake. The game takes you through a story of the 1930s
Date Reviewed:
Apr 15, 2021
Hours Played: 9
Beat the Game: Yes
Platform: PC
Fan of the Genre: Yes
Fan of the Dev: Yes
Fan of the Series: Yes
Skadess
8 / 10.0
Story: 9,5/10 Gameplay: 7,5/10 Content: 7,5/10 Characters: 8/10 Music: 8/10 Graphics: 8,5/10 Very nice game, a worse of a remake though.
Date Reviewed:
Apr 15, 2021
Hours Played: 80
Beat the Game: Yes
Platform: PC
Fan of the Genre: Yes
Fan of the Dev: No
Fan of the Series: Yes
This review contains SPOILERS! Click to expand.
Date Reviewed:
Dec 11, 2020
Hours Played: 67
Beat the Game: Yes
Platform: PC
Fan of the Genre: Yes
Fan of the Dev: No
Fan of the Series: Yes
Story... Original had some flaws, but the overall storytelling and immersion made me forgive the shortcomings, with the remake, it is the other way around. Unimportant things got improved, important ones got watered down or completely cut. Story wise great. Detail great.. Just a shame you dont let us look at the detail as free roam mode had no interiors to explore.. No trains
Date Reviewed:
Nov 13, 2020
Hours Played: 13
Beat the Game: Yes
Platform: PC
Fan of the Genre: Yes
Fan of the Dev: No
Fan of the Series: Yes
Social Play: Played mostly with friends
66evil66
Don't Buy
Even considering this game as a based on "Mafia The City of Lost Heaven" there are too many things that make you think this is a typical 2K Mafia game. Everything feels off, just like in Mafia 2, like dev team had some great ideas but for some reason they had to get rid of them. City is gorgeous, but empty, all cars feel the same and pretty fast (they should not be), narration
Date Reviewed:
Oct 8, 2020
Hours Played: 15
Beat the Game: Yes
Platform: PC
Fan of the Genre: Yes
Fan of the Dev: No
Fan of the Series: Yes
Sort by: