Should you play this if you loved the original: yes. Emphatically. And I say that as someone who's usually the first in the room to say a remake didn't need to exist. This isn't a lick of paint — the weather, the seamlessness, the diving, the combat all change how the game plays, not just how it looks. If you've never played Black Flag: this is where you start, full stop. Don't go back and play 2013 first out of some sense of duty — you'd just be signing up for stiffer combat and loading screens for no reason. You actually get the better deal here: the rest of us are quietly mourning a couple of cut things, and you get to just play the best version with no ghosts abord the vessel. Slightly jealous of you, if I'm honest.
Borderlands 4 is easily the strongest entry in the franchise is years. It refocuses the core, fun gameplay, build creativity and exploration. The narrative is better anchored, and the polish in many systems shows growth. It's not without its blemishes, where it does have some performance and optimization issues, however overall it is a very, very good game.
Atomfall is an ambitious and atmospheric survival RPG that delivers a compelling world and intriguing story. Its open-ended exploration and multiple endings make it a rewarding experience for players who enjoy uncovering mysteries at their own pace. However, its combat mechanics, technical issues, and occasional pacing problems hold it back from greatness. For those willing to overlook its flaws, Atomfall offers a unique and immersive adventure. But if you’re looking for polished combat and a more guided experience, you might find its rough edges frustrating.