Zachary Holmes


128 games reviewed
80.1 average score
80 median score
100.0% of games recommended
Are you Zachary Holmes? If so, email critics@opencritic.com to claim this critic page.
5.5 / 10.0 - House of Lost Souls
May 20, 2025

House of Lost Souls wants to be a thoughtful exploration of grief wrapped in a psychological horror experience. In some ways, it succeeds—it captures the emotional weight of returning to a place that holds nothing but pain. But the game can’t get out of its own way. For every genuinely creepy moment, there’s a broken door. For every emotional payoff, a badly delivered monologue. This is a haunted house game built on a good foundation—but one that desperately needs more time in development, better writing, and fewer ghost screeches.

Read full review

6 / 10.0 - POLARIS
Jan 29, 2025

POLARIS is a game with strong foundations, offering an exciting mix of destruction, flight-based combat, and cooperative gameplay. However, its lack of deeper progression mechanics, limited mission variety, and shallow looting system prevent it from being a truly standout title at this stage. If the developers continue iterating based on community feedback, adding more diverse objectives, refining combat balance, and expanding progression systems, POLARIS has the potential to evolve into something truly special. For now, it’s an enjoyable co-op shooter with solid mechanics, best played with friends, but lacking the depth needed for long-term engagement.

Read full review

6.5 / 10.0 - DeTechtive 2112
Mar 21, 2025

A gripping cyberpunk noir where every choice matters. Investigate dark secrets, sneak or shoot your way through cases, and uncover a mystery that may be better left unsolved.

Read full review

Jun 29, 2025

Super Engine GT Turbo SPEC is fun, accessible, and charming in its presentation, but ultimately limited in scope. It looks the part, plays smoothly, and feels nostalgic, but it runs out of gas too quickly for serious racing fans.

Read full review

6.5 / 10.0 - Pick Me Pick Me
May 28, 2025

Pick Me Pick Me is smart, funny, and completely original. It reinvents the dating sim by throwing in competitive PvP, live AI interactions, and unpredictable sabotage cards. It’s everything you didn’t know you wanted in a party game—until the tokens run out. If the devs shift to a one-time purchase or a more generous free-to-play system, this could be a breakout hit. Until then, it’s a brilliant game in a frustrating wrapper.

Read full review

6.5 / 10.0 - Warside
May 8, 2025

Warside is full of good ideas, solid mechanics, and clear passion—but it’s not ready for prime time. It plays like a polished prototype that slipped out under pressure. While it can be fun for tactics veterans, the bugs, balance issues, and lack of polish make it a hard sell at launch. Buy it if you’re patient, passionate about Advance Wars-style games, and willing to support development. Wait if you want a finished campaign, strong writing, or competitive multiplayer out of the box. That said, Warside deserves a second look in a few months—if the developers follow through on their patch roadmap. There’s a strong game in here. It just needs more time in the trenches.

Read full review

STAR WARS: Episode I: Jedi Power Battles is a fun but flawed blast from the past. For those who grew up with the original, this re-release offers a chance to relive the chaotic lightsaber battles and platforming mishaps that made the game memorable. However, if you’re expecting a full-fledged remaster with significant improvements, you might be disappointed. For newcomers, the game is still worth a try—especially if you have a friend to play with. Just be prepared for a few frustrating moments along the way. Ultimately, Jedi Power Battles is a game that thrives on its nostalgic charm, and for many players, that’s enough.

Read full review

Jan 27, 2025

Sniper Elite: Resistance is a solid yet unambitious entry in the franchise. It delivers the tactical sniping and stealth gameplay that fans have come to expect, but its heavy reliance on recycled content and lack of innovation prevent it from standing out. For die-hard fans, the game offers enough enjoyment to warrant a playthrough, particularly on sale. However, newcomers or those seeking a groundbreaking experience may be better served by revisiting Sniper Elite 5. Ultimately, Resistance feels like a missed opportunity—a competent but uninspired addition to a beloved series that’s overdue for a true evolution.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - NBA 2K26
Sep 8, 2025

NBA 2K26 is both an improvement and a letdown depending on your expectations. On the one hand, the gameplay is smoother, offense feels fantastic, and ProPLAY™ continues to make animations eerily realistic. On the other, defense is lackluster, microtransactions remain pervasive, and the PC experience is held back by poor anti-cheat and a small community. If you’re a hardcore basketball fan who enjoys grinding MyCAREER or collecting in MyTEAM, you’ll find hours of entertainment here. If you’re new or casual, be prepared for a steep learning curve—and possibly a steep cost if you want to compete at higher levels. It’s not the slam dunk fans have been begging for, but it’s at least a smooth layup that gets the job done.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Killing Floor 3
Jul 24, 2025

Bloody Good With Room to Grow. Killing Floor 3 is not a finished masterpiece, but it is a promising evolution. It understands the heart of the series: frantic co-op action, over-the-top gore, and tactical survival. Yes, it needs more content. Yes, it needs more polish. But it’s clear that Tripwire is laying the groundwork for something that can eventually surpass its predecessors. If you’re a fan of the franchise or just love mowing down mutant horrors with friends, Killing Floor 3 is already a blast. Just know you’re buying into a game still finding its full form. But with time, this could become the definitive Killing Floor experience.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - EDENS ZERO
Jul 15, 2025

EDENS ZERO isn't here to redefine the action RPG. It's a passion project, made for fans, by developers who clearly care about the source material. What it lacks in depth and budget, it makes up for with personality, charm, and sheer content density. It's cozy, nostalgic, and rewarding in the way only a certain kind of anime RPG can be.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Empyreal
Jun 30, 2025

Empyreal offers a deep dive into a mysterious world with challenging gameplay and rich features. Dive in for a rewarding action RPG experience!

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Rusty Rabbit
Apr 27, 2025

Pilot your trusty mech through frozen ruins as Stamp, a grumpy rabbit rust digger! Smash, loot, and upgrade your gear while uncovering secrets of a lost world ruled by bunnies.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Infected Dawn
Jun 23, 2025

Infected Dawn offers a tense mix of strategic resource management and eerie exploration—an immersive survival challenge for true zombie aficionados.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Mining Company
May 24, 2025

Mining Company is a mess—but it's your mess, and that’s where it succeeds. If you’ve got a crew of friends, some patience, and a taste for unpredictable co-op horror, this game is a $5 gamble that might just pay off in laughter, panic, and some very bad space trades. Just don’t expect it to hold your hand—or work perfectly. Mining with monsters, broken mic settings, and pure co-op chaos. Best served with friends.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - Back:Fade
May 18, 2025

Back: Fade is a hot mess—and it’s all the better for it. Equal parts terrifying and ridiculous, it’s a trashy horror gem that fans of FMV, cult cinema, and experimental storytelling will love. It’s not for everyone. But if your idea of a good time includes haunted birthday parties, possessed teddy bears, and dialogue so strange it could summon demons, Back: Fade is the experience you didn’t know you needed.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - The Precinct
May 15, 2025

The Precinct doesn’t reinvent the sandbox genre—but it does turn it on its head. Playing the cop instead of the criminal is a smart twist, and for a few glorious hours, it feels like a fresh take on old-school open-world chaos. The detail in procedures, the wild chases, and the sheer charm of the 80s aesthetic make this a memorable ride. But it's not without its problems. From bugs to repetitive systems, there's a rough layer that could frustrate more detail-oriented or single-player-focused players. The game shines brightest in its first act—and if Fallen Tree Games continues patching and expanding it, there’s a real gem buried beneath the jank.

Read full review

Mar 5, 2025

Orcs Must Die! Deathtrap isn’t just Orcs Must Die 4—it’s a faster, tougher, and more strategic evolution of the franchise that incorporates roguelite mechanics and a more skill-based approach to orc-slaying mayhem. For those who love intense action, dynamic traps, and cooperative strategy, this game is an absolute blast. However, its steep difficulty curve, shorter campaign, and potential reliance on paid expansions might leave some players hesitant. Should you buy it? If you enjoy challenging, fast-paced gameplay with roguelite progression, then absolutely. If you’re looking for a casual, traditional OMD experience, you might find this entry a bit too brutal. As it stands, Orcs Must Die! Deathtrap is a wildly entertaining game that keeps the spirit of the franchise alive—just with a much higher skill ceiling.

Read full review

Ambulance Life: A Paramedic Simulator is a solid foundation for an EMS simulation game, offering a level of medical depth rarely seen in the genre. It delivers a thrilling experience with high-pressure decision-making, a rewarding progression system, and intense large-scale emergencies. However, its immersion is undercut by AI inconsistencies, frustrating bugs, and missing realism-enhancing features. For those who enjoy simulation games, Ambulance Life is worth considering, especially with the potential for future updates and community-driven improvements. If you’re willing to look past its flaws, the game offers a unique and enjoyable take on the world of emergency medical response. With more polish, AI refinements, and additional features, it could become the definitive paramedic simulator.

Read full review

Apr 21, 2025

Into the Dead: Our Darkest Days is a gritty, promising survival sim that nails tone and tension—but still needs polish and balance to reach its full potential. It’s not for everyone. But for fans of This War of Mine or Project Zomboid who want an emotional, side-scrolling survival experience with real stakes, it’s worth watching—and maybe even playing now.

Read full review