Zachary Holmes


239 games reviewed
80.2 average score
80 median score
100.0% of games recommended
Are you Zachary Holmes? If so, email critics@opencritic.com to claim this critic page.
May 22, 2026

Is one of the best cozy cooking games available right now — charming, well-paced in its first half, genuinely fun in both competitive and relaxed modes, and full of characters that reward the time you spend with them. The late-game pacing issues and repetitive music are real gaps that post-launch updates could address, and they do bring the experience down from what it could be. But at $11.99 with 15-20 hours of content and an Overwhelmingly Positive reception on Steam, there’s no good reason not to pull up a chair in KuloNiku’s kitchen. One customer asked for a bowl with no ingredients except the condiments. Someone wanted a very spicy tofu dish with no soup. This is the energy of this game and it is exactly correct. For more cozy and sim game coverage, head to our full reviews section.

Read full review

7.5 / 10.0 - Thick As Thieves
May 19, 2026

Is a promising, unfinished, remarkably fun $5 game that filled an obvious gap in the co-op stealth market. The pedigree behind it is real, the core design is right, and the developer’s post-launch responsiveness suggests this has a genuine future if the sales numbers support continued development. It should have been Early Access. It wasn’t. Buy it for what it is — an excellent afternoon of co-op heisting and a proof of concept for something that could be great — not for the hypothetical product it might eventually become. For more stealth and indie game coverage, check out our full reviews section.

Read full review

9 / 10.0 - Esoteric Ebb
May 18, 2026

Is a remarkable achievement — a solo developer’s love letter to the CRPG and tabletop traditions that creates something genuinely new from familiar inspirations. The Disco Elysium comparisons will follow it everywhere and they’re not wrong, but they’re also not the whole story. Norvik is Bodegård’s city. The Cleric is his character. The humour, the warmth, the political earnestness — these are his voice, and by the end of a playthrough they’re entirely recognisable as such. At $24.99, Esoteric Ebb offers more genuine creativity per dollar than almost any other CRPG on the market. The rough edges and occasional over-reliance on its inspirations are the honest price of a singular creative vision. For fans of Disco Elysium, Planescape: Torment, and narrative RPGs generally — this is absolutely essential. For more RPG coverage, check out our full reviews section.

Read full review

Is the best TMNT VR game that could realistically be made at this budget, and for the franchise’s VR debut, that’s more than good enough. The parkour traversal is excellent, the Turtle weapon differentiation is smart, the story is legitimately written, and the co-op chemistry — when it works — is exactly the kind of chaotic fun the franchise deserves. The shallow combat, sparse open world, and co-op progress bug are real limitations that keep it from being more. At $24.99 for VR owners who have friends to play with, Empire City is easy to recommend. Solo players without TMNT nostalgia may find the experience thinner. We’re looking forward to revisiting this on the Steam Frame when it arrives — a more capable headset may push the experience closer to its potential. For more VR and action game coverage, check out our full reviews section.

Read full review

Is a genuinely good Dark Pictures game wearing the costume of a different game entirely. The Turning Points system is a series-best addition. The story pays off. The presentation is outstanding. But the wholesale replacement of the series’ established tension mechanics with repetitive stealth, the absence of the Curator, and the missing online co-op at a significantly higher price point all conspire to make this feel less than the sum of its parts for the franchise faithful. If you’re new to Supermassive’s work, Directive 8020 is a strong entry point into cinematic horror gaming — atmospheric, well-acted, and narratively satisfying. If you’ve played every previous entry and loved what made them distinct, temper expectations and perhaps wait for a sale and the post-launch co-op update. For more horror and adventure game coverage, check out our full reviews section.

Read full review

7.5 / 10.0 - Blades of Fire
May 14, 2026

Is a game of exceptional ideas imperfectly executed — which is exactly what you’d expect from a studio that has spent its career taking ambitious swings. The forging system is genuinely great. The directional combat, at its best, is distinctive and rewarding. The world is beautiful and the soundtrack is outstanding. And the Version 2.0 improvements represent real value for players arriving fresh on Steam. But the Crimson Fort escort mission, the enemy input-reading frustration, and the navigation opacity of the opening dungeon are real obstacles that drive players away right when the game needs them most. If you have tolerance for friction and an appreciation for genuine mechanical ambition, Blades of Fire has enough to offer that it’s worth the $29.99 introductory price. If you need a smooth experience from hour one, try the demo first — it’s an honest representation of the early game, but not of everything that follows. For more action-adventure coverage, check out our full reviews section.

Read full review

May 13, 2026

Is the most promising debut chapter in mascot horror since the genre became its own thing. Skunx Games has built something with a distinct voice, a genuinely great soundtrack, creative puzzle mechanics, and mascot designs that have already found a dedicated community. The late-game chase frustrations and navigation issues are real — but they’re also exactly the kind of things that get smoothed out across an episodic series as developers learn from player feedback. At $6.70, there is essentially no reason not to play this if you have any interest in the genre. For more horror, indie, and gaming coverage, check out our full reviews section. The Omeletteman Song will haunt you. We cannot be held responsible for this.

Read full review

May 11, 2026

Is the best the franchise has ever felt in a video game format, and a genuinely strong roguelite regardless of its licence. Alt Shift understands both the source material and the genre well enough to make something that serves both masters effectively. The procedural narrative events, the survival-focused combat, and the meaty progression system combine into an experience that’s far more than a branded reskin. The lack of new lore, the long run times, and the absent camera controls hold it back from greatness. But for BSG fans and strategy roguelite veterans who’ve been waiting for this exact combination, Scattered Hopes delivers on the promise. So say we all. If you’re looking for more strategy and roguelite recommendations, check out our full reviews section for more of our latest coverage.

Read full review

7 / 10.0 - INDUSTRIA 2
May 8, 2026

If you played and enjoyed the original INDUSTRIA, this is an easy recommendation — the sequel improves on every dimension that matters narratively and atmospherically, and the roughness of the launch is being addressed actively. If you’re new to the series, the 4-6 hour runtime at $24.99 is reasonable value for what’s here, especially with the introductory discount active. Our honest advice: either grab it now knowing you’re buying into a work in progress, or wait 60-90 days for another patch cycle to clear the most disruptive bugs. Either way, this is an indie team with vision and craft, and INDUSTRIA 2 at its best shows exactly what Bleakmill is capable of when everything clicks. We’re rooting for them to get there.

Read full review

9 / 10.0 - Far Far West
May 6, 2026

Is the real thing. It’s a genuinely outstanding Early Access launch from a tiny team that understood exactly what makes PvE co-op shooters work and built something new on top of that foundation. The supernatural Wild West setting is inspired, the spell-and-gun combat is satisfying and team-friendly, and the polish on display defies both the team size and the price point. The Early Access balance notes are real but minor, and Evil Raptor’s responsiveness to feedback makes them feel like speed bumps rather than warning signs. At $17.99 during the introductory period for a game that has already delivered 10-hour sessions to tens of thousands of players, Far Far West is one of the best value propositions in gaming right now. Saddle up.

Read full review

May 3, 2026

Is the best thing to happen to the killing game genre since Danganronpa V3. Where most spiritual successors flatten the formula into imitation, Mango Factory understands it deeply enough to push it somewhere new — a grittier, stranger, more atmospherically unsettling place that feels like the genre finally growing up without losing its charm. Episode 1 has rough edges: borrowed beats that sell its originality short, minigames that need tuning, and a card battle system that hasn’t yet found its full footing. But the cast is extraordinary, the atmosphere is unlike anything else in the genre, and the narrative hook at the end of the episode is genuinely stunning. At $13.49 for what’s here, it’s one of the best-value purchases of 2026 so far. Get in early — this one’s going to be something special when it’s complete.

Read full review

Apr 30, 2026

Is exactly the conclusion this series deserved. Dvora Studio has gone bigger in every dimension — more characters, more locations, more combat, more story payoffs — while preserving the tense, atmospheric run-and-hide horror that made the franchise worth following in the first place. The art direction is the best in the series. The lore resolution is genuinely satisfying. The Korean occult atmosphere remains one of the most distinctive and underappreciated qualities in indie horror. Enemy balancing at launch and the occasionally disruptive character swap pacing prevent it from being a clean 9. But at under $12 during its introductory period, Bloodlines is an easy recommendation — both as a series conclusion and as a strong entry point into Dvora Studio’s haunted world. The nightmare ends here. It ends well.

Read full review

8 / 10.0 - Bus Bound
Apr 30, 2026

Impressive achievement in accessible sim design. stillalive studios have made a bus game that’s welcoming to newcomers without talking down to fans of the genre, built around a driving model that holds up across dozens of sessions and a city that rewards your investment in it. For players willing to accept the gamified structure rather than fight against it, this is among the most enjoyable transport sims ever made. The compromises are real — no continuous driving, limited fleet depth, no solo bus traffic — and players expecting a pure simulation will find Bus Simulator 21 still offers the more complete hardcore package. But as an accessible, polished, and genuinely fun driving experience that anyone can pick up and enjoy, Bus Bound earns a confident recommendation at $29.99. The city is waiting. You might as well take the wheel.

Read full review

Apr 29, 2026

Is a game that earns genuine admiration even as it frustrates. The core concept — emotions as cards, narrative as deckbuilding — is one of the more original ideas in the genre, and the world The Rat Project has built around it is atmospheric, beautifully drawn, and fully voiced in a way that belies the team’s size. These are real achievements worth celebrating. But the execution doesn’t always match the vision. Balance issues, a rigidity to the deck system, and pacing that occasionally loses momentum prevent Magin from reaching the heights its ambition promises. For players who embrace commitment, enjoy dark narrative RPGs, and are willing to build with intent rather than experiment freely, there’s a genuinely compelling experience here. For everyone else, it’s a game that’s easier to respect than to love — but respect it you will.

Read full review

7.5 / 10.0 - Puddle Knights
Apr 26, 2026

Puddle Knights is a genuinely fun Early Access co-op roguelike with creative mechanics, strong moment-to-moment gameplay, and one of the more interesting build systems in the genre. The eating mechanic alone is worth the price of admission, and the co-op experience with a group of friends is chaotic in all the right ways. The mixed Steam reviews are understandable — disconnect issues, the lack of lobby rejoin, and limited solo appeal are real friction points that will put some players off. But for $9.99 with a developer who’s clearly invested in improving the game, Pebble Knights represents a promising foundation that’s already delivering genuine fun. If you have three to four friends ready to play and can tolerate some Early Access roughness, this is easy to recommend right now. Everyone else should wishlist it and check back at full release.

Read full review

9.5 / 10.0 - Causal Loop
Apr 23, 2026

Casual Loop is a remarkable achievement. A three-person team has built a game that belongs in the same conversation as Portal and The Talos Principle — not as a pale imitation, but as a genuine peer. The echo mechanic is one of the most inventive puzzle systems in years, the alien world of Tor Ulsat is a joy to explore, and the narrative carries genuine emotional weight bolstered by a strong fully-voiced cast. Minor frustrations around death resets, precision platforming, and an underused sub-mechanic prevent it from being a flawless experience. But given the team size, the budget, and the asking price, these are genuinely minor complaints. If you enjoy puzzle games, sci-fi narratives, or simply want to see what dedicated indie development looks like at its absolute best, Causal Loop is a must-play.

Read full review

7.5 / 10.0 - Tides Of Tomorrow
Apr 21, 2026

Tides of Tomorrow succeeds as a bold experiment in narrative gaming that pushes the medium forward in meaningful ways. While it has rough edges and gameplay elements that don't always land, the Story-Link system represents genuine innovation that creates experiences impossible in any other medium. This is the kind of game that matters beyond its immediate quality—it's exploring new possibilities for how we connect through interactive storytelling. Digixart has created something that feels like the future of narrative gaming, even if it's not quite perfected yet. For players willing to engage with its experimental nature and environmental themes, Tides of Tomorrow offers a uniquely meaningful gaming experience. You're not just playing a story—you're contributing to a living narrative that will continue long after your playthrough ends. In a gaming landscape often focused on individual achievement, Tides of Tomorrow dares to suggest that our choices matter most when they affect others. That's a message worth supporting, wrapped in a game worth playing.

Read full review

8 / 10.0 - Replaced
Apr 19, 2026

REPLACED is a remarkable achievement that demonstrates how indie developers can create experiences that rival big-budget productions through focused vision and exceptional artistry. While it has flaws that prevent it from reaching perfection, the core experience is so compelling that these issues fade into the background. This is exactly the kind of ambitious, thoughtful game that deserves support. Sad Cat Studios has created something genuinely special—a cyberpunk tale that asks important questions while delivering stunning visuals and solid gameplay. For anyone interested in narrative-driven gaming or exceptional pixel art, REPLACED is an essential experience. In a year full of impressive indie releases, REPLACED stands out as a genuine masterpiece that will likely become a cult classic. Don't let this digital soul's journey pass you by. – ColdMoon

Read full review

8.5 / 10.0 - Aether & Iron
Apr 17, 2026

Aether & Iron is a remarkable achievement that successfully blends genres and creates something genuinely fresh in the RPG space. Despite some technical rough edges and limited mechanical depth in certain areas, the game's strong narrative focus, innovative combat system, and gorgeous presentation make it an easy recommendation for players seeking something different from their RPG experiences. In a gaming landscape often dominated by sequels and safe choices, Aether & Iron dares to be different—and largely succeeds. This is exactly the kind of ambitious indie title that deserves support, and we're eager to see what Seismic Squirrel creates next in this fascinating universe. – Flare

Read full review

8 / 10.0 - Town of Zoz
Apr 15, 2026

Town of Zoz is a hidden gem that wears its GameCube-era inspirations proudly on its sleeve. Studio Pixanoh has managed to successfully blend the satisfying, top-down combat of classic Zelda titles with the wholesome, relationship-building agricultural loops of Stardew Valley. While the painfully slow opening hours and minor UI bugs require a bit of patience, the gorgeous cel-shaded art style, deep cooking mechanics, and lovable cast of characters make the journey entirely worthwhile. If you are looking for a cozy, nostalgic adventure with a surprising amount of mechanical depth, Town of Zoz is serving up exactly what you need.

Read full review