Jay Castello


20 games reviewed
86.0 average score
Are you Jay Castello? If so, email critics@opencritic.com to claim this critic page.
Unscored - Stardew Valley
Mar 30, 2024

It’s unclear whether there’ll be a massive 1.7 update in the future. Barone has been developing a different game, Haunted Chocolatier, since 2020, and while that’s currently on pause to get 1.6 bug-free and available across platforms, surely at some point Stardew Valley will be left to its own devices. But even if it doesn’t get any more major updates, its unshakeable core, long tail, and rooted community mean that it’s bound to stay at the center of the ecosystem that grew up around it for a long while to come.

Read full review

Mar 15, 2024

A satisfying daily loop turns into a speedy momentum in this open world farming game, but its early access release raises questions that need answers.

Read full review

Jul 1, 2023

I’m thrilled that the remaster has given Ghost Trick a new lease on life. But Sissel spends the whole game making sure that nothing falls through the cracks — and that just doesn’t square with his game’s now lonely survival.

Read full review

Feb 17, 2023

Anyone who’s spent any time in fandom circles knows how a little goes a long way when it comes to filling in the gaps in character relationships. A hand on a shoulder, a passing compliment, a little joke — anything can be fuel for the imagination. There was plenty of time in Octopath Traveler 2, during exploration and combat, when my mind was free to wander and would have done most of the work — if there was any foundation for me to build from. But I can’t help feeling that imaginative fuel wasn’t put into the script to begin with. Without it, Octopath Traveler 2 is beautifully realized, but there’s a hole at its center.

Read full review

Unscored - Pentiment
Nov 14, 2022

Because even though Pentiment is set in the past, it demonstrates how history is never static, and how it influences places, communities, and individuals. That’s something that’s easily lost when we look back through time, but Pentiment’s living characters and spiraling mystery won’t let you forget it.

Read full review

Unscored - Butterfly Soup 2
Oct 31, 2022

Butterfly Soup 2 is a sequel that lives up to the heartbreak and hilarity of the original, while giving an even more compassionate exploration of teenage life.

Read full review

Unscored - Roadwarden
Sep 8, 2022

Roadwarden is a beautifully written fantasy world with more mystery than can be solved in a single playthrough, and that's what makes it so intriguing.

Read full review

Unscored - The Waylanders
Feb 1, 2022

The Waylanders is an RPG that's endearing as it is janky. It has fun characters and looks stunning, so here's hoping that more patches can get rid of the (potentially game-breaking) bugs.

Read full review

Unscored - Moonglow Bay
Oct 25, 2021

A little frustrating in places, but Moonglow Bay is mostly a chill fishing RPG that digs into its themes of community, resilience and rebuilding in surprising and consistently interesting ways.

Read full review

Unscored - Hades
Sep 17, 2020

Supergiant’s action roguelike was already a game of the year contender when it first came out in early access two years ago. It definitely is one now.

Read full review

Sep 16, 2020

There’s nothing in the way of making me feel like I’ve become awfully clever at it all.

Read full review

Unscored - Necrobarista
Jul 21, 2020

Necrobarista realises that there are no objectively correct answers to the questions it raises about mortality, loss, and how to live a good life. In giving these two characters their different resolutions without presenting either as better than the other, it manages to acknowledge that while simultaneously giving both a satisfying conclusion.

Read full review

Navigating a world of wonder, an intrepid trader encounters a succession of strangers in this engaging narrative card game

Read full review

Mar 19, 2020

The latest addition to the demon-slaying franchise is a gorgeously designed gore fest that delivers relentless fun

Read full review

Unscored - Besiege
Mar 2, 2020

While I’ve been writing this, I’ve still been playing Besiege, in a way. Ideas for new creations have been bubbling away under the surface of my mind, just waiting for me to hop back in and build them

Read full review

Sep 20, 2019

This is objectively good game design, but it’s also desperately endearing.

Read full review

Jul 26, 2019

Beyond: Two Souls feels like a Frankenstein creature; a television show with interactivity jammed in for the sake of it.

Read full review

Jan 17, 2019

YIIK might have been able to get away with some of its issues if other areas were able to pick up the slack.

Read full review

No Recommendation / Blank - Bomber Crew
Jul 9, 2018

Bomber Crew takes the FTL formula to WW2, but it can be a bit of a bumpy ride.

Read full review

Jan 3, 2018

An entertaining, light-hearted point-and-click adventure game full of memorable characters and wholesome British humor.

Read full review