Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

Back to Summary

Percentile Rank

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is ranked in the 25th percentile of games scored on OpenCritic.

Rating Summary

Based on 37 critic reviews
Weak Man

OpenCritic Rating

65

Top Critic Average

14%

Critics Recommend

Based on 37 critic reviews

Score Distribution

Unscored Reviews

Eurogamer
No Recommendation / Blank
No Recommendation / Blank
Jun 7, 2016

Another rewarding glimpse inside the mind of London's greatest detective that's a little too old-fashioned and clumsy to shine.

Read full review

ACG
Wait for Sale
ACG

Top Critic

Wait for Sale
Jun 7, 2016
Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter Review "Buy, Wait for Sale, Rent, Never Touch?" - YouTube video thumbnail
Rock, Paper, Shotgun
Unscored
Unscored
Jun 10, 2016

Nu Watson and Holmes look dangerously close to Downey Jr and Law, five years too late, and their new voices are bizarrely unenigmatic, if competently delivered. It's not a reboot, nor a refresh, right down to the repeated locations and character models of the likes of Lestrade, but rather the weirdness of the series continuing its morbidly fascinating spiraling descent into lunacy. If I find myself carrying on, I'll certainly let you know what happens next, but in the meantime, yeah, avoid.

Read full review

Scored Reviews

Video Chums
8.5 / 10.0
8.5 / 10.0
Dec 24, 2016

I'm delighted by how far Frogwares has taken the Sherlock Holmes franchise.

Read full review

SelectButton
8 / 10
8 / 10
Jul 18, 2016

With varying action sequences, Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter attempts to appeal the series to a wider audience. Almost every case features new mechanics that you'll only use once before moving on, but thankfully these can be skipped if you desire. I've skipped a couple in my playthrough, and never felt like I was taking the easy way out. Why waste time on a poorly constructed trial and error sequence, when I just want to figure out who set the streets of London ablaze in a hailstorm of fire. When it comes down to it, The Devil's Daughter is still a fun experience, giving players the freedom to come to their own conclusions. It's a great way to feel like you are a detective.

Read full review

PlayStation Universe
8 / 10.0
8 / 10.0
Jun 7, 2016

Over eighteen months on from the release of Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments and there still hasn't been anything quite like it on PS4. Trust the developers of that game then to be the ones who surpass it with Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter, an effort that not only meaningfully evolves over its predecessor but also one that sadly suffers from a small handful technical issues, making it fall just shy of greatness. All the same, the fact remains that sleuthing about Victorian London has never been as entertaining as this.

Read full review

Everyeye.it
7.7 / 10.0
7.7 / 10.0
Jun 19, 2016

Sherlock Holmes-The Devil�s Daughter is born from below, affected by a quite limited financial investment, which can be seen through its weak technical part. Yet, it has tried to remedy to this lack by offering an excellent gaming variety, with a less linear and more compelling progress. It is a small but necessary step forward for this franchise.

Review in Italian | Read full review

Nation Fusion
7.6 / 10.0
7.6 / 10.0
Mar 6, 2017

With all the blustery fury of a two-year-old, many Americans vowed to leave the country if their candidate didn't win. While some of us burst into song after the votes were tallied, others began preparing for the apocalypse. Even if this season does feel a bit different and more sinister, us Yanks must admit it was always thus. If you are packing your things and currently have plans to leave the country, this article is for you. I'd highly recommend a quick stop in England before you go, to maybe cool you head a bit with some solid detective gameplay in Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter. It worked for me.

Read full review

GamingTrend
75 / 100
75 / 100
Jul 11, 2016

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter continues to be one of the best adventure/puzzle games around. It has nearly perfected the deduction system, but the contrived action sequences forced into the new title can be very frustrating. While one is slightly disappointing, five of the six new cases are quite enjoyable and features all the twists and turns you could hope for. Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is another solid entry into this long-running franchise.

Read full review

Wccftech
7.4 / 10.0
7.4 / 10.0
Jun 10, 2016

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is a competent adventure game featuring a varied and well crafted gameplay experience, charming characters and engaging stories. The game still suffers from some issues, such as the the trial and error nature of the action sequences and the excessively long load times, which prevent it from being really great. With a few adjustments and improvements, the Sherlock Holmes formula could become the standard for adventure games of the future, as achieving such gameplay variety is no small feat. Highly recommended to fans of the series and adventure games' fans.

Read full review

Push Square
7 / 10
7 / 10
Jun 7, 2016

Whether it's sniffing out clues with Holmes trusty basset hound, planning an elaborate diversion in slow motion like you're in a Guy Ritchie film, or dodging spike pits and giant rolling balls a la Indiana Jones, the Sherlock games are always throwing something different at you. Devil's Daughter focuses more on story, with a larger plot taking over from the case work in satisfying ways. Some extended sequences of button mashing can become tiresome and the moral choice system doesn't add anything substantial, but the overall experience is great fun.

Read full review

VideoGamer
7 / 10
7 / 10
Jun 7, 2016

A decent adventure game with lots of ropey bits. Just like the last one, and the one before it.

Read full review

TrustedReviews
Jun 8, 2016

If Frogware could just tighten up the good stuff and lose what doesn't work, it might just give us the ultimate Sherlock Holmes game. As it is, The Devil's Daughter is flawed but entertaining, with lots of great detective work, some fun if baffling storylines and annoying action bits you can cheerfully skip through.

Read full review

Impulsegamer
3.5 / 5.0
3.5 / 5.0
Jun 21, 2016

It is a game with potential, but its frustrating game design flaws prevented it from being a 'must play'. I felt there was a bit of confusion as to the direction the developers wanted to go, as they couldn't quite marry the point and click and action adventure genre together. There is a lot to explore and the ability to play as different characters, point your finger at multiple suspects and use Holmes's abilities to piece together clues is great, but the action sequences and lack lustre storyline (until the very, very end) really let the game down. If you are a Sherlock fan and can overlook these flaws then you will enjoy the variety and new detective abilities offered in this adventure, otherwise maybe give this one a miss.

Read full review

Press Start
7 / 10
7 / 10
Jun 8, 2016

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil’s Daughter feels about on par with previous games in the series.

Read full review

PressA2Join
7 / 10.0
7 / 10.0
Jun 8, 2016

"In my opinion the best title in the series to date, Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is a nice step in the right direction for Frogwares and the popular investigative series in general. Its graphics fit nicely with the current generation console even if its action sequences sometimes flatter to deceive".

Read full review

games(TM)
7 / 10
games(TM)
games™ Team

Top Critic

7 / 10
Jul 19, 2016

The best yet, but still short of greatness

Read full review

Game Informer
6.8 / 10.0
6.8 / 10.0
Nov 2, 2016

Technical problems and odd diversions pull down another Sherlock Holmes adventure

Read full review

God is a Geek
6.5 / 10.0
6.5 / 10.0
Jun 9, 2016

While The Devil's Daughter does a lot of things adequately, it does absolutely none of them spectacularly, and feels like a bit of a misstep for the series.

Read full review

GBAtemp
6.5 / 10.0
GBAtemp

Top Critic

6.5 / 10.0
Jun 9, 2016

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter isn't necessarily a bad game. Each individual case is written rather well, voice acting is about as good as you can expect, and some of those puzzles along the way work well enough to keep the game challenging, but fun. It still looks good and offers that "Holmes" feel, but unfortunately no game is perfect. Bad puzzles and poor performance can easily kill the pace of the game, and with only four and a bit cases you'll find the content as a whole a bit lacking for $50.

Read full review

GameGrin
6.5 / 10.0
GameGrin
Borja 'VodKaVK' Henry Vilar Martos

Top Critic

6.5 / 10.0
Sep 13, 2016

The Devil's Daughter is a collection of minigames sewn together with a very questionable story, but that manages to keep the player amused for the duration of the game. Particularly given the atmosphere crafted in every detail of London and the deduction mechanics, the game will often make you feel like Sherlock.

Read full review

Gamefa
6 / 10.0
6 / 10.0
Jul 27, 2016

This game is recommended to hardcore Sherlock fans, otherwise, fans of adventure games won't find this game memorable at all. The Devil's Daughters doesn't offer much more than the previous installment of the series.

Review in Persian | Read full review

Xbox Achievements
60%
60%
Jun 7, 2016

A better presented package overall, Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is a small step forward for the series, but still in serious need of polish and a greater level of cohesion between its disparate parts. Fewer mini-games and more sleuthing would have been preferable and played to the game's strengths. As it is, The Devil's Daughter is a solid Sherlock yarn, but one that falls well short of greatness.

Read full review

GameSpot
6 / 10
6 / 10
Jun 7, 2016

Sherlock's powers of deduction are as enthralling as ever, but middling action gets in the way.

Read full review

TrueAchievements
Jun 12, 2016

Frogwares has taken the best bits from Crimes and Punishments and has added to them for The Devil's Daughter. The problem is that these additions aren't always good. Accompanying the improved point and click gameplay are action sequences that add variety to each case, but they are also clumsy and prone to outstaying their welcome. Unfortunately the game's engine is also showing its age and loading times can often feel interminable. This title offers a typical Sherlock Holmes storyline and an easy completion, but its issues turn this into a mediocre affair rather than the elementary experience that you would expect from Holmes himself.

Read full review

Telegraph
Jul 6, 2016

The Devil's Daughter is an enjoyable thriller. Albeit one that doesn't always know its strengths.

Read full review

NZGamer
6 / 10.0
6 / 10.0
Jun 23, 2016

With a bit more polish, and a few much needed scenes, this game could be amazing.

Read full review

GameSpew
6 / 10
6 / 10
Jun 8, 2016

Frogwares' past Sherlock Holmes games… have always been unexceptional interpretations of the world's most exceptional detective, at times displaying some moments of brilliance, but mostly held back by their ineptitude and desire for safety

Read full review

ZTGD
6 / 10.0
ZTGD

Top Critic

6 / 10.0
Nov 17, 2016

For those who have already played [Crimes and Punishments], Devil's Daughter will provide the same fix in the same way that a low fat version of your favorite food does, in that it's not as satisfying as you would like it to be. It doesn't help any that Devil's Daughter also offers less game for more money. It's a shame, because the story here is enjoyable and the ending has some legitimately tense moments, but almost everything about it feels like it could have, and should have, been better.

Read full review

TheSixthAxis
6 / 10
6 / 10
Jun 7, 2016

I'd love to be able to give Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter a stronger review, but it simply isn't possible. The story is solid, if a little unusual for a Sherlock Holmes tale, and the collection of mechanics and mini-games that could easily feel thrown together actually work well together, leaving you guessing about what comes next.

Read full review

PC Gamer
59 / 100
59 / 100
Jun 20, 2016

An increased focus on action and unsatisfying cases overshadow the decent bits in this detective adventure.

Read full review

GamingBolt
5 / 10.0
5 / 10.0
Jun 24, 2016

This is far from Frogwares' worst effort till date but Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is far from the detective's greatest adventure yet.

Read full review

Next Gen Base
5 / 10
5 / 10
Jun 14, 2016

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter feels like a let-down. Crimes & Punishments was far from perfect, but it felt like clear progress – this latest effort feels like treading water at best.

Read full review

Rocket Chainsaw
Jul 3, 2016

There is some elementary adventure to be found here, but new players looking for a real Sherlock Holmes experience would find better material in some of the previous installments.

Read full review

We Got This Covered
Jun 14, 2016

The base gameplay of Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter allows you to pick the brains of the great detective while testing your deductive skills. It's just a shame that long loading times and grating puzzles constantly interrupt any intrigue found within the vague stories.

Read full review

Cubed3
5 / 10
5 / 10
Mar 6, 2017

When it's not suffering from an identity crisis, Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is a fine adventure/mystery game. Each case is intelligently designed and some aspects are really fascinating. Drawing conclusions from deductions is satisfying, especially when the right call is made. However, far too much time is spent engaging in distractions. This game would be much more fulfilling if it stuck entirely to what makes Sherlock Holmes great. That means no pointless activities, no misguided characterisation, just a plethora of mysteries that are fun and interesting to solve.

Read full review

PCWorld
Jun 20, 2016

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is a hard left over Reichenbach Falls. It's Frogwares taking all the wrong lessons from Crimes and Punishments, turning out its least-coherent Sherlock games in ages and filling it with all sorts of mechanical drudgery. Such a shame.

Read full review