Andrew McMahon


68 games reviewed
71.1 average score
70 median score
44.8% of games recommended
Are you Andrew McMahon? If so, email critics@opencritic.com to claim this critic page.
8 / 10.0 - PGA TOUR 2K25
Feb 20, 2025

PGA Tour 2K25 comes back strong, with substantial changes to how it looks and plays bringing it within striking distance of the competition.

Read full review

6 / 10.0 - Undisputed
Oct 7, 2024

Undisputed does a lot of new and interesting things in the boxing genre, but also fails to connect in several key areas.

Read full review

Sep 24, 2024

EA Sports FC 25 is going to be much like the game you remember from last year. While FC IQ and roles do a good job of making tactics feel varied and exciting, there are many adjustments and improvements that need to be made to AI before things feel balanced. When slide comes to tackle, not too much has changed this year.

Read full review

Recommended - NBA 2K25
Sep 9, 2024

There are still plenty of improvements to be made, but there's also no doubt that NBA 2K25 is one of the best games in the sports genre at the moment.

Read full review

Recommended - Madden NFL 25
Aug 19, 2024

While it does feel like the same strides and missteps occur each year, Madden 25 has more positive improvements than bad...[we're] happy with the realistic changes that have come about with FieldSENSE and BOOM Tech, as well as the various presentation updates that have been added.

Read full review

8 / 10 - Dustborn
Aug 14, 2024

If you are looking for a good narrative adventure that respects your ability to choose and explore, Dustborn is for you.

Read full review

Jul 24, 2024

EA Sports College Football 25 proves it's more than just nostalgia with its impressive production and gameplay.

Read full review

6 / 10 - Capes
May 24, 2024

Capes mostly overcomes its cliches, lack of customization, and limited scope thanks to its strategic gameplay that will test the mettle of even the most hardened of turn-based tactics veterans.

Read full review

May 8, 2024

Solo Leveling Arise is authentic to its anime and webtoon inspirations, but it's too grindy, frustrating, and repetitive to come close to rivaling the best gacha games.

Read full review

5 / 10.0 - The Invincible
Nov 2, 2023

The Invincible might have a strong inspiration in the 1964 novel, but every time it attempts to make it more interesting as an interactive experience it ends up doing the opposite.

Read full review

4 / 10.0 - EA Sports FC 24
Oct 4, 2023

While it isn’t another literal copy-and-paste of last year’s version, EA Sports FC 24 is still leagues worse on Nintendo Switch.

Read full review

Mar 16, 2023

Here’s to hoping that Magic Design Studios gets the recognition it deserves for crafting one hell of an underworld experience and that it’ll be able to build upon it even more from here.

Read full review

When all is said and done, I really think the story, characters, and overall loop of Persona 3 Portable are vital for anyone that is on the fence about the series. And despite showing its age a bit in sections, the combat is still rewarding and satisfying, solidifying the game’s place as one of the premier RPG titles in all of gaming. I genuinely believe it’s also going to be the reason I get back into Persona 5 and can truly come to appreciate what everyone else loves about the game so much.

Read full review

1.5 / 5.0 - Choo-Choo Charles
Dec 9, 2022

If you’re looking for a scary Spider Train experience that’ll get your heart rate going, you’re probably just better off watching that Spider-Man 2 scene where everyone keeps Peter Parker’s secret. At least that way, you’ll have seen a good movie instead of playing a video game that was simply made because the idea sounded good in theory.

Read full review

Dec 2, 2022

Despite some of these shortcomings, Marvel’s Midnight Suns is still a blast to play, as you get to really experience what it’s like to be a powerful superhero, thanks to excellent gameplay mechanics. It’s just a shame that they didn’t flesh things out just a little bit more when it comes to the world and how it wants to tell its narrative and portray these iconic superheroes, as that would have made it a truly elite game in the genre.

Read full review

Oct 20, 2022

If you love the previous game or just are really craving a good giggle, New Tales from the Borderlands is most definitely a must-play title for you in 2022. I happily give this one a rating of 4 and a half skateboards out of 5.

Read full review

Here’s to hoping that when Naughty Dog does decide to eventually return to the series, they’re sure to also bring it to PC, as its grand scope just feels magnificent when it’s pushed to its highest possible limits.

Read full review

4 / 5.0 - Saints Row
Aug 22, 2022

Overall, anyone who was a fan of the franchise before this will likely still love Saints Row, as the comedy, goofiness, and chaotic gameplay is still at the game’s core. And while I wasn’t a fan of how they went about the story, there’s definetly some promise in regards to its more grounded focus, as it seems clear this reboot was made to push the series into an interesting new direction.

Read full review

Aug 10, 2022

You can keep your Elden Rings and Horizon Forbidden Wests; I’ll be on my cult farm raising crops and occasionally sacrificing my followers for the rest of the year, as Cult of the Lamb is an easy front runner for Game of the Year.

Read full review

3.5 / 5.0 - Hindsight
Aug 3, 2022

That isn’t to say that Hindsight is by any means a bad game. The story is excellent, the art is fantastic, and a lot of people are going to relate to its message. However, if you’re going into the game thinking that it is going to be the next big breakout indie of the year, then you might come away a little disappointed.

Read full review