The Academy: The First Riddle Reviews

The Academy: The First Riddle is ranked in the 11th percentile of games scored on OpenCritic.
TheSixthAxis
Top Critic
6 / 10
Jul 9, 2020

The Academy isn't a bad game, per se, but promises far more than it delivers. Its influences are too clearly worn on its sleeve and it ends up less than the sum of its parts. The school is too small and the puzzles just not exciting enough to really draw you in. The target audience is probably much less jaded than me and younger players will probably enjoy the combination of Hogwarts-esque schooling and puzzles, but it's a difficult title to recommend for experienced puzzle gamers.

Read full review

6 / 10
Jun 24, 2020

The Academy has the kind of premise that should make it feel more special than it is. It certainly shines with its different array of puzzles. But the game's characters and their dialogue make this feel as exciting as Algebra class. I should feel more excited about the extracurriculars, but instead, The Academy's shortcomings had me watching the clock and waiting for the bell to ring.

Read full review

7.5 / 10.0
Jun 24, 2020

A boarding school adventure packed full of puzzles, The Academy combines Proffesor Layton and Harry Potter to provide hours of classroom antics. If you can cope with some cumbersome controls, you'll find plenty of pop quizzes and mysteries to solve within.

Read full review

70 / 100
Jun 25, 2020

At $17.99 on Steam at the time of writing, it's hard to beat up The Academy: The First Riddle too much. It's a lot of fun, it's value priced, and the developers are actively engaged with the community and prepping patches for much of the things I've mentioned. Could it be better at launch? Certainly. Does it deliver a compelling stack of puzzles that'll have you scratching your brain for hours? Absolutely. We have to give credit to Pine Studios for trying something new, even if they might have gotten a C on that "Debugging" class.

Read full review

PC Invasion
Top Critic
4 / 10
Jun 19, 2020

The Academy has a weak narrative, poor puzzles, and game-breaking bugs. This is one invitation you're going to want to avoid.

Read full review

2.5 / 10.0
Jun 19, 2020

The Academy is a mess of a game, with terrible puzzles, characters and plot. Don't bother.

Read full review

4.5 / 10.0
Jul 2, 2020

A decent world dragged down by repetitive gameplay, dreadful writing, and awkward animations.

Read full review

B-
Aug 13, 2020

The Academy: The First Riddle is a fun game. Puzzle fans should keep an eye out for it and even hope for a "Second Riddle". If you aren't a puzzle fan, The Academy may not put you under its spell.

Read full review

Geeks Under Grace
Johnathan Floyd
7 / 10.0
Jun 26, 2020

The Academy: The First Riddle is a good puzzle game for kids, and decent for keeping your mind sharpened.

Read full review

Jul 8, 2020

The Academy: The First Riddle is a mystery puzzle adventure game that takes players to boarding school, but it fails to make top marks.

Read full review

3 / 5.0
Jun 26, 2020

I was so, so excited for The Academy: The First Riddle, and although I feel pretty letdown by the experience, I believe there’s still something to it. It’s entirely possible that the dev team works everything out within the next few months and the flaws are ironed out, leaving only pure puzzle goodness to grace our screens.

Read full review

8 / 10.0
Jun 23, 2020

Overall, The Academy provides a lot of entertaining puzzle solving and an entertaining storyline. While some of the puzzles are confusing or arguable, you get that in pretty much any puzzle game, and the few number of issues with understanding puzzle solutions really speaks for how well they're put together. There are plenty of puzzles, and enough little side missions to keep you entertained for a while. There are enough hint items floating around to help you through the core of the game, and they're easy enough to earn if you put the effort in. The Academy is an enjoyable puzzle solving experience that I would recommend to anyone coming off a Layton bend, or looking for some riddles to solve.

Read full review

GameSpace
Top Critic
7 / 10.0
Jun 22, 2020

A solid set of puzzles and a gorgeous world are largely let down by some odd narrative decisions and middling character development that are just jarring enough to prod you out of the world that Pine Studio has worked so hard to craft. If you’re looking for a Layton style experience in an extraordinary world then this could be for you. Otherwise, take this one at your own pace because school life can be tough at Arbor Academy.

Read full review

8 / 10.0
Jun 19, 2020

As a huge fan of both puzzle games and Harry Potter, I’m definitely a part of their target audience. What I wasn’t prepared for was just how creative and clever the puzzles would be.

Read full review