Strange Antiquities Reviews

Strange Antiquities is ranked in the 91st percentile of games scored on OpenCritic.
7.8 / 10.0
Sep 22, 2025

Strange Antiquities is a successful sequel that echoes the strengths of its predecessor, but this time with a more engaging theme and polished presentation. The controls still betray this as a PC game through and through, but on the Nintendo Switch 2, it works surprisingly well. The biggest disappointment remains the lack of voice acting, which sometimes makes the shop feel quieter than you'd like. And visually, I would have preferred a darker and more consistent style. But these are minor details in a game that otherwise excels in atmosphere and puzzle design. It's cozy, mysterious, and offers precisely those little riddles that you'll happily solve in a few minutes. For fans of the first game, this is a must-have, and for new players, an excellent entry point into the strange world of Undermere.

Review in Dutch | Read full review

86 / 100
Sep 18, 2025

Strange Antiquities is a charming and cozy occult puzzle game that is surely a treat for budding detectives and puzzle-lovers. With its simple point-and-click gameplay that complements a variety of complex challenges and riddles that require extra brainpower, this puzzle game will surely take you on a spooky but intriguing text adventure through the town of Undermere and the secrets that lie within.

Read full review

Mind-blown
Sep 16, 2025

Strange Antiquities is a welcome return to the moody town of Undermere. It is what you would like from a cozy game for Autumn – strange artefacts, quirky characters, a moody soundtrack, a cat you can pet, and of course, an overarching mystery to solve.

Read full review

9 / 10.0
Sep 15, 2025

Running Strange Antiquities feels like a mix of puzzle-solving, catalogue work, and moral choice. Each day is a self-contained session that takes about twenty to thirty minutes, which makes it perfect for short bursts of play. You spend your time identifying artefacts, cross-referencing your tomes, and deciding which object might help (or hinder) the townsfolk. ... Strange Antiquities is a masterclass in atmosphere. The game captures that balance of dark and cosy that makes Undermere such a compelling place to return to day after day. The rain at the window, the candlelight across your shelves, and Juniper’s quiet presence all weave together into something that feels both homely and haunted.

Read full review