Mafia: The Old Country Reviews
Mafia: The Old Country offers a beautiful yet traditional experience. It seeks to honour the legacy of the series by returning to its roots, but it fails to take a step forward either in gameplay or storytelling. While it may captivate fans of gangster worlds with its visual beauty and strong character performances, it might disappoint those looking for genuine innovation in the series.
Review in Arabic | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country is the best Mafia game yet. Foregoing some storytelling tropes and poor game design choices of its predecessors, tightening its gameplay, and telling the most gripping story in the franchise to date, capped off by outstanding performances by the whole cast and a looker to boot, Mafia: The Old Country shines amongst its siblings and is an offer you shouldn't refuse.
Mafia: The Old Country is a no-nonsense, back-to-basics experience, and its dedication to authenticity serves as its best attribute. By sticking to a tight, linear experience, The Old Country allows the performances and writing to do the heavy lifting without losing the allure of the Sicilian countryside. By bringing to light a specific place in time that few movies or games have gone before, there's a wealth of details you'll come to appreciate.
Mafia: The Old Country marks a welcome return for the series, trading the excesses of modern open worlds for a tight, story-driven experience. Historical authenticity, strong characters, and a beautifully recreated Sicilian setting make it both engaging and cinematic. Unfortunately, a barebones, uninnovative gameplay, underwhelming knife duels, and simplistic AI hold it back. While Enzo Favara’s journey remains a significant chapter, it’s not quite enough to restore the series to its former glory.
Review in Italian | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country is a worthy return to form for the Mafia series. It's not perfect, but it strikes a fine balance of great storytelling, compelling characters and dramatic twists to keep you hooked.
Mafia: The Old Country pairs simple, standard mechanics with a predictable mob narrative, but its gorgeous period setting and tight, story-driven run make for a thrilling experience.
Mafia: The Old Country is a solid title, but definitely not a game to remember, nor one that brings anything new to the series. The story is decent, and it’s nice to see familiar characters return, but beyond that, everything else is pretty average.
Review in Unknown | Read full review
It’s worth noting that Mafia: The Old Country won’t demand hundreds of hours of your time. I clocked it in just shy of 12 hours, doing so in about four short sessions. The game features an exceptional storyline that is well-told through its structure, with a strong emphasis on story over substance. If you’re after an open-world style experience like GTA or Saints Row, then sadly, this won’t be what you’re looking for. However, if you’re after a well-executed and rich story with beautiful visuals, fantastic voice acting, and you aren’t overly bothered about a linear structure with fairly shallow mechanics, then you’ll love it. It is a good Mafia game, but I don’t feel it’s the best out of the bunch so far.
Despite the mixed feelings stemming from the experience of the third chapter and the excellent remake of the first, Mafia The Old County manages to steer the series back on the right track thanks to the bold choices made by the development team. Using an effective narrative, it offers a glimpse into organized crime during a little-explored historical period, set in a carefully recreated part of early 20th century Sicily. Not only is the Sicilian dialect voice acting outstanding, but the entire sound design of the title is above average quality.
Review in Italian | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country had the potential to be a much bigger and better game than it is. The story is weak at several points, fails to deliver a satisfying ending, and its gameplay also suffers from issues.
Review in Portuguese | Read full review
The saving grace of Mafia: The Old Country is its linear focus. There is not a single point in this game where I was asked to explore the large open map or search for some resource to get arbitrary upgrades. This linear focus and a 10-hour run time kept me from ever getting frustrated or annoyed with my experience, even if I never felt particularly engaged throughout. I’m not mad that I spent my time with Mafia: The Old Country, but for such a focused experience to feel so bland is ultimately disappointing.
Mafia: The Old Country is a game that undoubtedly has its problems and imperfections. It is not a perfect production, but it is definitely worth giving it a try. The Old Country may have a simple and unoriginal story, but the way it was written and executed deserves all the praise it gets. Following Enzo's story is truly engaging and can evoke a lot of emotion. It's simply a great gangster series that draws you in from the very first minutes.
Review in Polish | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country aims to take Hangar 13's work back to its roots, both in terms of the anthropological and historical origins of the criminal organisation and those of the video game franchise. The work done is commendable: we were captivated by a story and characters that were very well written. But what fascinated us even more was the historically accurate rendering of the setting and the passion with which the American developers committed themselves to conveying a period so full of colour, but also of shadows. Of course, we would have liked to lose ourselves even more deeply in this beautifully painted world, but Mafia: The Old Country does not want to lose its way and wants to accomplish its mission in the best possible way.
Review in Italian | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country is a cinematic mob saga that excels in atmosphere, storytelling, and gameplay depth. While it’s not without flaws, especially in pacing and polish, it offers a compelling experience for fans of stealth, crime dramas, and immersive world-building. If you can push past its quirks, there’s a rich, blood-soaked tale waiting to be unravelled.
Nearly a decade after the poorly received Mafia 3, Hangar 13 returns to early 20th-century Sicily with Mafia: The Old Country—a visually stunning, story-rich yet predictable adventure whose charming 14-hour journey is only undermined by underwhelming combat and occasional performance issues.
Review in Dutch | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country is a familiar tale with simple gameplay, yet the excellent acting and gorgeous backdrop give enough reasons to check it out.
Although the gameplay isn’t going to win any awards, Mafia: The Old Country still delivers what people love about the franchise. It’s a great crime story featuring a new protagonist that holds up with the others in the series and is a nice story-driven experience overall.
Mafia: The Old Country doesn't try to reinvent the wheel, but rather returns to its roots and once again places the greatest focus on a cinematic and suspenseful story with compelling and interesting characters.
Review in Unknown | Read full review
Mafia: The Old Country delivers a concise experience anchored by a well-crafted, albeit highly predictable, storyline that can be finished in a weekend. While the narrative doesn’t break new ground, it remains engaging enough to carry players through to the end, thanks in large part to strong performances. Unfortunately, the gameplay struggles to keep pace. Its simplicity isn’t inherently a flaw, but when paired with repetitive design and underwhelming enemy AI, it becomes clear that the story is doing most of the heavy lifting. The result is a game that feels narratively rich but mechanically underdeveloped.
Mafia: The Old Country is like opening an old bottle of Sicilian wine: the flavor is intense, familiar, and comforting, but you notice that time has left it with a touch of age. It shines in its setting, characters, and leisurely narrative, but it resists modernizing its gameplay, remaining a game that will delight lovers of the genre and mafia stories, while leaving those looking for something more wanting more.
Review in Spanish | Read full review